Holy Smithereens!

Travel Ideas for the Luxurious Adventurer

  • Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • Destinations
  • PR / Media
  • Contact

The Problem with World’s Best Island Titles. (A Midnight Rant)

July 4, 2013 by Jean Holy Smithereens Leave a Comment

 

Travel + Leisure recently published their ‘World’s Best Awards 2013’. They listed what their readers deem to be the world’s best cities, hotels, spas, islands, cruises, and others.

Being an island and underwater lover, I of course paid attention to the World’s best island list. The whole list can be viewed here but here’s a snippet:1009738_10151685671644509_265802974_n

When I saw Palawan topping the list, I felt really proud ! Not just because I’m originally from the Philippines, but I am truly, madly , deeply in love with Palawan. Is it world’s number 1 island for me? I don’t know, I’ll get back to you on that when I’ve explored ALL the islands in the world! All I know is that my time in Palawan was supercalifrajamazing!

IMG_0039
Snorkelling in Twin Peaks, Coron, Palawan

and then I saw the island that was ranked number 2, Boracay. I know, I know, beauty is in the eye of the beholder but…er, I really want to know what the beholder was on to love this:

20130525_094020
i do not relax well in crowds. Boracay at 8 am
P1030426-001
the best snorkelling spot in Boracay- dead city

I’m not a Boracay-basher. It used to be my one true love! And so the hurt cut deep when I returned to it in such a state.. And yes, yes perhaps the beholders stayed at the Shangri-la Boracay. But I believe we are ranking islands, not hotels. The best island should be enjoyed by everyone, regardless of where they stay , such as Palawan.

Anyway, I understand the importance of yearly lists. People who do not have time to research extensively rely on it where to go. But my problem with lists is that it encourages a culture of ‘what’s hot/what’s not’ among islands, cities and countries. So when Boracay was listed as world’s number 1 island in 2012 by Travel + Leisure, I can only imagine the surge of tourists who came to the island. Tourism is not bad. It means the place is a-buzzing! Locals have jobs! But when a lovely island becomes over-commercialised to accommodate or attract more tourists, that’s when things turn sour.

Yes I encourage you to enjoy the lists, read them. Use it as a guide to determine where to go. But make sure you research independently too. And the most important thing that I wish to say is, go beyond anybody’s list. Create your own and have fun exploring lesser known places!

P1030444
Caramoan is one of the best islands i’ve ever been to. it’s a pain to get there. and it hasn’t made the cut to any lists (yet).

While some of the best places I’ve been to are still unheard of, the other best moments too have been in ‘bucket-list’ stereotype places where the hype is definitely real, and more.

Bora-Bora. A veteran in many bucket lists. And well deservedly so.
Bora-Bora. A veteran in many bucket lists. And well deservedly so.

Don’t snub a place just because you haven’t heard of it yet or because it’s unpopular. But don’t avoid places too just because you think ‘everyone’s been there already!’ Neither should you just limit your travelling to places that are high up in the ‘cool’ list.

In other words, when being a traveller– be open to all places. This way if everyone travelled equally to all places, no island will be overcrowded.

Every island wang-chung! 🙂

P1030163
Dear Palawan, please remain just the way you are.

———————–

What do YOU think of this year’s 2013 best island list??

 

«
»

Filed Under: Adventure, Uncategorized

About Jean Holy Smithereens

Jean is a lover of luxury travel and adventure, always looking for that "Holy Smithereens"-inducing moment on her travels. Follow the blog and other social media pages of Holy Smithereens to get the ultimate travel ideas for the luxurious adventurer!

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

LET’S GET SOCIAL

  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

INSTAGRAM

--
[instagram-feed]
  • Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • Destinations
  • PR / Media
  • Contact

Copyright © 2023 · Web Design by Fancy Girl Design Studio